David Adrian (galadrion) wrote,
David Adrian

  • Mood:
  • Music:

The Return of the King

Ye gawds, I'm glad I saw it.  The whole trilogy.  I feel absolutely vindicated in saying it's this generation's "Star Wars" trilogy.

Yes, there were some things left out of the movies.  I wish - oh, how I wish - Peter Jackson had included the whole sequence involving Tom Bombadil - Old Man Willow, Tom himself, Goldberry, and the Barrow-Wights. 

Bree and the acquisition of Bill the pony might have been nice - particularly Sam's shot at Bill Ferny with the apple core. 

Shelob should've been in the second movie, not the third, and the orcs of Cirith Ungol could have been fleshed out a great deal more. 

The Sacking of Orthanc, with Wormtongue throwing down the Palantir and earning the wrath of Saruman.  The Breaking of Saruman's Staff, for that matter. 

Denethor's Palantir, and the visions which drove him to madness - especially the coming of the Black Fleet.

The unfurling of Aragorn's banner as the Black Fleet arrived.

Perhaps even the Scourging of the Shire - though I'm with Peter Jackson on this one: it didn't really add much to the story beyond wrapping up what happened with Saruman and Wormtongue, and giving the Four a chance to return as heroes, conquering once again.

Yes, all of these could have been added - though to do so would have probably made the trilogy about fifteen hours long.  I'd have been willing, and more than willing, to sit through them.  I think most people would be.

A thought occured to me while I was sitting in the theater, talking with a few of the others who were also there waiting.  The conversation had turned to comparing The Lord of the Rings with the Harry Potter stories, and how both were faring on the translation between book and film.  It seems to me that there's a growing trend among audiences - a preference for grand, even epic tales is emerging... or rather, re-emerging.  People have flocked to the Tolkein trilogy, despite the length of each of the movies, and the general consensus among those I've spoken to seems to indicate that they'd have enjoyed it even if the movies were longer - they'd prefer it if the films were even more true to the books, even if it ran over four or even five hours per film.  The Harry Potter films, likewise, seem to have audiences wanting the movies to be more true to the books, even at the expense of running longer than conventional "wisdom" says films can succeed with - and those movies are facing an even worse situation than Peter Jackson's movies did.  The first one remain fairly close to the book - though Peeves was omitted - but the second one left out even more.  I can't see how the third one is going to avoid even more glaring omissions, and beyond that - yeesh.  Those books have been getting longer each time, and the writing more densely-packed.  The director(s) are going to have a problem keeping Goblet of Fire under three hours, I think.

So here's what the group I was talking came up with.  For those movie-makers working on epic stories such as these, it might be an idea to consider returning to the days when movies had an intermission - remember those? - and go with longer running times.  Had the Lord of the Ring movies gone to, say, four or five hours apiece, I'd be willing to watch them, even at a ticket price of, say, $10 or so - and I wasn't alone in that.  It would certainly allow directors such as Mr. Jackson to tell the stories they're capable of, in the fashion that the stories deserve.  So, am I nuts, or am I onto something here?


  • Writer's Block: Best book ever!

    Many. This is why my home is a bibliophilic event horizon - I don't get rid of books.

  • Writer's Block: Kill the music

    Hey There Dililah - and for 24 hours, I would need a lot of money... after taxes. And if the check bounces, you're a dead man.

  • Possible recipe rough draft

    This is actually an initial rough draft for an idea I/we had tonight, inspired by... well, I need to explain. Y'see, Kestrelcat is, among other…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.